Insurance Broker vs Agent vs Aggregator: Who Should Companies Use?

Key Takeaways

• Most companies buying group or commercial cover are better served by a licensed insurance broker, because a broker is legally bound to act in the client’s interest while an agent is appointed by, and represents, the insurer.
• Under the IRDAI (Appointment of Insurance Agents) Regulations, 2016, an individual agent cannot hold agency appointments with more than one life insurer, one general insurer, one health insurer and one of each mono‑line insurer.
• A corporate agent may tie up with up to three insurers in each of the life, general and health categories, following the 2022 amendment to the IRDAI (Registration of Corporate Agents) Regulations, 2015.
• A web aggregator, under the IRDAI (Insurance Web Aggregators) Regulations, 2017, maintains a website for price comparison and product information across insurers, which suits retail products rather than negotiated corporate programmes.
• Every direct broker must hold professional indemnity cover of two times its annual remuneration subject to a minimum of one crore rupees, under Regulation 24 read with Schedule II Form S of the IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018.
• A single policy cannot carry both broker remuneration and agency commission, so the channel chosen at placement is the channel that services the policy for the year.

The three channels are not three flavours of the same service. They sit in different regulatory categories, owe duties to different parties, and are paid under different rules. An agent is appointed by an insurer and solicits that insurer’s products. A web aggregator runs a comparison website and passes leads to insurers. A broker is registered by IRDAI in its own right, takes a written mandate from the client, and is required by its code of conduct to act in the client’s interest. For a company buying group health, liability or property cover, where the policy is negotiated rather than picked off a shelf, that difference in who the intermediary answers to is the whole decision.

What is the difference between an insurance broker, an agent and a web aggregator?

An insurance broker is an entity registered under the IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018 as a direct, reinsurance or composite broker. The regulations describe a direct broker’s functions in advisory rather than transactional terms: obtaining detailed information about the client’s business and risk management philosophy, familiarising itself with the underwriting information so it can be explained to insurers, advising on appropriate cover and terms, submitting quotations for the client’s consideration, and assisting in the negotiation of claims. An insurance agent is appointed by an insurer to solicit and procure that insurer’s business, so the agent’s product range is bounded by who has appointed them. The 2016 regulations define a composite insurance agent as an individual appointed by two or more insurers on the condition that they shall not act for more than one life insurer, one general insurer, one health insurer and one of each mono‑line insurer. A corporate agent, typically a bank or distribution company, operates under a separate 2015 regulation and, since the 2022 amendment, may hold up to three tie‑ups per category. A web aggregator is described by IRDAI as an intermediary maintaining a website that lets prospects compare prices and view product information across insurers, under regulations effective 13 April 2017. The model is built for products that can be displayed, filtered and bought without underwriting negotiation. That describes most retail motor, travel and individual health business, and almost no corporate programme.

Who does each channel legally represent?

The answer sits in the regulations rather than in market convention. Schedule I Form H, the code of conduct every broker must follow, opens by requiring that every insurance broker shall discharge their functions in the interest of the clients or policyholders. The same code requires a broker to ensure the client understands on whose behalf it is acting, and to obtain a written mandate from the client to represent the client to the insurer. An agent has no equivalent client mandate, because the appointment belongs to the insurer. That is not a criticism of agents, who are regulated, examined and often highly capable. It is a structural fact about where the duty sits. When a group health renewal returns with a heavier loading than last year, an agent’s ability to challenge it is bounded by the insurer that appointed them, while a broker holding your mandate can take the same submission to the wider market. The practical test is short. Ask which entity appointed the person in front of you, how many insurers they can approach, and whether they will give you a written mandate.

How does each channel get paid?

Distribution remuneration changed on 1 April 2023, when the IRDAI (Payment of Commission) Regulations, 2023 replaced product‑wise commission caps with an approach tying total commission to each insurer’s expenses of management limits under a board‑approved policy. There is no longer a single published percentage to look up for a given product. Two rules matter more to a corporate buyer than the percentage does. Under Regulation 26, no remuneration can be paid where agency commission is payable, and no agency commission where remuneration is payable, so a policy travels through one channel rather than two. A broker may also charge a client fee for risk management services under Regulation 27, but only for commercial risks, only on written confirmation from the client, and not in addition to remuneration for the same service. At renewal, ask which basis applies to your programme and get the answer in writing before inception.

What can a broker do that an agent or an aggregator cannot?

Registration as a broker carries obligations that operate, from the client’s side, as protections. A direct broker must hold minimum paid up capital of seventy five lakh rupees under Regulation 19, keep net worth above fifty lakh rupees under Regulation 22, and maintain a ten lakh rupee bank deposit under Regulation 23. Regulation 24 then requires professional indemnity cover throughout registration, set by Schedule II Form S at two times annual remuneration, subject to a minimum of one crore rupees for a direct broker. If a broker’s advice on a wording is wrong and your company suffers a loss, a regulated indemnity stands behind that advice. The code of conduct adds duties an interface cannot replicate. A broker must explain why a policy is proposed and compare price, cover or service where there is a choice, ensure the policy suits the client’s needs, explain the procedure to follow after a loss, and disclose all material facts within its knowledge to give a fair presentation of the risk. That last duty decides contested claims. A comparison screen cannot present a factory’s fire risk to an underwriter. Edify Insurance Brokers works in this space, as a Bengaluru based corporate broking and risk consulting practice founded in 2015 by insurance professionals, structuring programmes across Employee Insurance, property and transit, liability and specialty lines, with an HR dashboard and employee app holding policy, claims and document access in one place.

Which channel should your company use?

Match the channel to the complexity of the risk and to how much the wording matters.

• Broker suits negotiated corporate programmes: group health, group term life, group personal accident, liability, property and marine, and any cover a customer contract or lender requires you to hold.
• Agent suits a single, standardised policy where you already know the insurer you want and nothing is being customised.
• Aggregator suits retail purchases by individuals and quick price discovery on standardised products.

A company buying Group Health Insurance for the first time usually meets the difference at the second event rather than the first. Divergence appears when an employee’s claim is queried, when a room rent sub‑limit turns out to bite, or when renewal returns loaded on a claims ratio nobody has explained. Working through that first purchase now? The employer checklist for choosing group health insurance covers the specification decisions that follow this one. One tax point is often confused with the channel question. Individual life and health premiums became exempt from GST on 22 September 2025 under Notification No. 16/2025 Central Tax (Rate), while group and employer‑sponsored policies continue to attract 18%. Confirm your own position with your chartered accountant.

How do you check that an intermediary is properly licensed?

Verify the category before you weigh the pitch. IRDAI publishes lists of registered brokers, corporate agents and web aggregators, and a registration certificate states its category and validity. Ask for the registration number and category, ask who the Principal Officer is, ask for confirmation that the professional indemnity policy is in force, and ask how a complaint escalates to the insurer’s grievance function. A firm that answers all four without hesitation has thought about the parts of the relationship that only matter when something goes wrong, and the About Edify page sets out the leadership behind that work.

Conclusion

Choosing between a broker, an agent and an aggregator is not a preference. It decides who owes you a duty, how many markets you see, and who is on the hook if the advice is wrong. For individual retail cover, an aggregator or an agent is often adequate. For a group or commercial programme, the broking mandate exists because someone needs to be on your side of the table. If your company is buying business insurance for the first time and wants this decision settled before specification work starts, Contact Edify with your headcount, sector and the covers you are being asked to hold.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

---

Publishing pack

Source register

Every statutory figure, date and regulation below was verified against a live source on 9 September 2026. Nothing in the post is written from memory.

Claim used in the post	Source	Where verified
Broker acts in the client’s interest; must ensure client understands on whose behalf it acts; written mandate to represent the client	IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018, Schedule I Form H, Code of Conduct, paras 1 and 2(c) and 2(h)	irdai.gov.in / gazette text of the 2018 Regulations
Functions of a direct broker (advice, market knowledge, submitting quotations, assisting claims negotiation)	IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018, Schedule I, para 1	Gazette text of the 2018 Regulations
Direct broker minimum paid up capital seventy five lakh rupees	IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018, Regulation 19(1)	Gazette text of the 2018 Regulations
Net worth floor of fifty lakh rupees for a direct broker	IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018, Regulation 22(1)(i)	Gazette text of the 2018 Regulations
Deposit of ten lakh rupees with a scheduled bank	IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018, Regulation 23(1)(i)	Gazette text of the 2018 Regulations
Professional indemnity mandatory; two times annual remuneration, minimum one crore rupees for a direct broker	IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018, Regulation 24 and Schedule II Form S, para 3(a)	Gazette text of the 2018 Regulations
No remuneration where agency commission is payable, and vice versa	IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018, Regulation 26(1)(a), Explanation	Gazette text of the 2018 Regulations
Broker may charge a client fee for risk management services on commercial risks with written confirmation	IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018, Regulation 27	Gazette text of the 2018 Regulations
Individual agent limited to one life, one general, one health and one of each mono‑line insurer	IRDAI (Appointment of Insurance Agents) Regulations, 2016, Regulation 2(6) and Regulation 3(3)	Official PDF of the 2016 Regulations (licindia.in mirror of the IRDAI text)
Corporate agent may tie up with up to three insurers per category (nine in total)	2022 amendment to the IRDAI (Registration of Corporate Agents) Regulations, 2015	irdai.gov.in corporate agents page and published legal commentary
Web aggregator defined as an intermediary maintaining a website for price comparison and product information across insurers; regulations effective 13 April 2017	IRDAI (Insurance Web Aggregators) Regulations, 2017	irdai.gov.in/intermediaries/web-aggregators
Product‑wise commission caps replaced by expenses of management linkage from 1 April 2023	IRDAI (Payment of Commission) Regulations, 2023	irdai.gov.in and published legal commentary
Individual life and health premiums exempt from GST from 22 September 2025; group and corporate policies remain at 18%	Notification No. 16/2025 Central Tax (Rate) dated 17 September 2025, following the 56th GST Council meeting of 3 September 2025	financialservices.gov.in exemption notice
Input tax credit on health and life cover blocked except where obligatory under a law in force	Section 17(5)(b), CGST Act, 2017, and its proviso	CGST Act text and published tax commentary